Archive for June, 2010
Decentralisation minister says new rules will make development more popular with locals
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
Heneghan Peng unveils first images of Greenwich architecture school
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
Penrose watch
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
One in 10 English churches needs urgent repairs
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
English Heritage survey uncovers repairs backlog of £900m, most of which is heavily dependent on shrinking grant aid
The condition of one in 10 places of worship is causing grave concern, according to a survey released today by English Heritage.
A sample of England's 14,500 listed places of worship – the largest single category of listed buildings – was surveyed in detail for the report. It found 10% in need of urgent and usually hugely complex and expensive repairs, a further 30% in poor condition, and the remainder lovingly maintained through heroic efforts by often tiny congregations.
English Heritage estimates there is a backlog of over £900m worth of urgent repairs, often due to lack of basic maintenance such as on roofs and gutters.
Major repair and conservation work is heavily dependent on grant aid, but those sources are precarious – English Heritage will inevitably have to make further budget cuts as government spending cuts bite. The main Heritage Lottery Fund-backed grants scheme is only assured until 2013, and a special provision for places of worship introduced by Labour, where the Treasury refunds the VAT – levied on repairs but not on new build, despite years of campaigning by conservation groups – runs out next year.
The situation being tackled by Andrew Mottram, at a group of churches in Dudley, represents an extreme example of all the problems spelled out in the report.
Mottram, a former vicar, is one of a growing national network of support officers, jointly funded by the church authorities and English Heritage. His job is to worry about hundreds of churches across the diocese of Worcester, advising on repairs and new uses to keep the buildings open and purposeful in the heart of their communities.
Every one of Dudley's seven large churches, four of them listed, has intractable problems. And while they have enough space for 5,000 worshippers, there is a total congregation in the town of fewer than 400 and falling.
The churches were built mainly in the 19th century for a boom town in the west Midlands with full employment in the metalworking industry. They now stand in a blighted landscape of derelict buildings, closed factories, shops and workshops, cleared sites, shuttered abandoned pubs with tattered "for sale" signs flapping in the wind. Right in the centre Beatties, the department store which was once the pride of the town, is also shuttered and desolate, its lifeblood drained by the out of town Merry Hill shopping centre. Even a nearby sex shop has a sign on the door offering "new lower prices".
There is a local authority town centre regeneration scheme, but it won't lap up the hills as far as most of Mottram's churches.
There's lovely St Thomas's, Grade II* listed, its magnificent spire held together with rusting iron clamps, with 25 people rattling around among seats for 1,000.
There's St James's, where the urgent job of replacing all the leaking gutters and downpipes has just been downgraded to second most urgent when great chunks of stone dropped off the tower, two days before hundreds of children were due to march through the door below for a school service. The vicar, Andrew Wickens, has been offered a repair grant by English Heritage, but has just learned he can't raise the match funding.
And then there's St John's. Mottram sighs. Everyone sighs at the mention of St John's.
St John's stands, just, on top of Kates Hill, with a dazzling view from its steep churchyard which holds the grave of a local hero, the 19th-century boxer nicknamed the Tipton Slasher. The church itself is closed and fenced off, windows boarded, cracked walls streaked with damp and mould, concrete surrounds cracking ominously and littered with freshly fallen chunks of stone. A heavy new concrete tile roof 30 years ago did more damage to the structure than the leaking slates it replaced.
Richard Stanton, who now lives in Bridgnorth, has come back to visit the graves of his parents. "It's awful to see it like that, I remember it full of people every week," he says sadly.
A dauntless preservation society is running a little charity shop and cafe next door, but it's going to take a lot of 20p tombola tickets and 30p glasses of squash to save St John's. The congregation has moved into the red-brick church hall across the road, beside the derelict pub: they would like to see the church restored, but they don't want to move back into the great cold draughty barn.
The diocese and the congregation are so sensitive about the state and possible future of St John's they don't even want it photographed.
Mottram is brutal: "This building is knackered. It might be rescuable – but it's going to cost a heck of a lot of money."
Key findings
The first English Heritage report on England's 14,500 listed places of worship at risk found:
• Approximately 10% are potentially in need of urgent major repairs.
• At least £925m worth of overdue repairs must be done in the next five years.
• For two-thirds of congregations, funding major repairs is a constant source of worry.
• Without the £25m a year repair grants scheme, joint funded by English Heritage and the Heritage Lottery Fund, 76% of repair and maintenance projects could not have been completed in the past eight years, and up to 266 places of worship would have closed because their condition was so dangerous.
• One in five said they could not have done repairs without the Treasury scheme which refunds VAT for repairs on places of worship. This runs out next year, just as VAT is set to increase from 17.5% to 20%.
Heatherwick’s pavilion scoops the Lubetkin
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
46 year old architectural technician is boxing heavyweight champion
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
Norman Foster at 75: Norman’s conquests
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
As the great British architect Norman Foster turns 75, he talks to Jonathan Glancey about flying cars, his new underground city – and how he beat bowel cancer
"The other day," says Norman Foster, "I was counting the number of aircraft I've flown: from sailplanes and a Spitfire to a Cessna Citation. By chance, it comes to 75." So Foster, who turned 75 this month, has decided to make models of all 75, to hang in his own personal museum, which he keeps at his Swiss home, an 18th-century chateau set in vineyards between Lausanne and Geneva.
These model aircraft will hover over his collection of some of the 20th-century's greatest machines, cherished for both their engineering brilliance and streamlined beauty; many of them look like winged or wheeled versions of Foster's most innovative buildings. "At the moment," says the architect, "I'm restoring a Citroën Sahara, designed to tackle north African dunes. I'm also thinking of getting a Bell 47 helicopter as a focal point. And I've had a model made of the Graf Zeppelin airship."
This last item puts me in mind of 30 St Mary Axe, aka the Gherkin, the Zeppelin-like London skyscraper that bears witness to Foster's passion for engineering marvels – a passion that began in childhood. Five years ago, I asked the architect if he had ever been a railway enthusiast. He replied by postcard, with a sketch of a Royal Scot class 4-6-0 thundering along, just as he would have seen it from his bedroom window, in the terraced house in Manchester where he grew up.
Foster has come a long way from those zinc-bath-in-front-of-the-fire days. The boy who left school at 16 to do his national service with the RAF is now – as his astronomical career shows, and as Deyan Sudjic writes in his new biography – "a phenomenon". But the lad from Levenshulme never forgot what he saw and learned as a working-class child brought up in an industrial Britain.
"There's a snobbery at work in architecture," says Foster, speaking at his riverside studio in Battersea, London. "The subject is too often treated as a fine art, delicately wrapped in mumbo-jumbo. In reality, it's an all-embracing discipline taking in science, art, maths, engineering, climate, nature, politics, economics. Every time I've flown an aircraft, or visited a steelworks, or watched a panel-beater at work, I've learned something new that can be applied to buildings. Disciplines connect, from locomotive engineering to the design of a bridge, or from a study of the way raptors and gliders soar. The most amazing lesson in aerodynamics I ever had was the day I climbed a thermal in a glider at the same time as an eagle. I witnessed, close up, effortlessness and lightness combined with strength, precision and determination. "
Foster's own rise has been no less impressive. His relentless enthusiasm and bristling energy had propelled him into the architectural stratosphere by the mid-1980s. Today, Foster and Partners is a global concern that employs 1,000 architects, working on an enormous number of projects: universities, skyscrapers, hospitals, museums, schools, production plants and entire city centres, stretching from Argentina and Brazil to Mumbai and Beijing, via London, Germany, Istanbul and the Middle East.
These range in scale from the India tower, a needle-like skyscraper in Mumbai that could end up being the world's tallest building (the height has yet to be finalised), to a sustainable school in Sierra Leone made of timber and mud-bricks. The former is an exuberant expression of the booming Indian economy; the latter a modest structure paid for by the Foster family.
Like all architectural firms, Fosters has been rocked by the recession. "In spring 2009, we had to lose 400 staff," he says. "Economic downturns hit architecture hard, but we've been recruiting again for several months. Now, we've accelerated into India, South America and parts of the Middle East, like Abu Dhabi, where economies are performing well."
Foster has, over the past decade, been criticised for building on too prodigious a scale. With so many designs on the go, and so many architects on the books, it hasn't always been possible to maintain the level of innovation and quality displayed in the firm's best works. These would include Berlin's Reichstag, a powerful remodelling of the original German parliament building torched in 1933 and now crowned with a mesmerising glass dome; the Viaduc de Millau (with Michel Virlogeux), the awe-inspiring French roadbridge over the Tarn valley with masts as high as the Eiffel tower; and the Hearst tower in New York, an eyecatching 46-storey skyscraper with a triangular exposed steel structure, rising provocatively from the top of a listed 1920s publishing HQ.
Most architects would give their souls for a sliver of his commissions. Which building is he most proud of? Always the one he is working on next, he says, although he is rightly fond of the beautifully detailed Hong Kong and Shanghai bank, opened in 1986 and built to aerospace standards of design, detailing and construction, with a budget (£500m) to match.
Essentially apolitical, Foster doesn't like to get involved in architectural spats, although he did sign a letter, along with other architects, denouncing the Prince of Wales's interference in the planning process for the redevelopment of the old Chelsea Barracks site in London. This is partly because Richard Rogers, battling the prince here, is an old friend, but also because Foster, although hugely successful, knows how hard winning major commissions can be; the wrong sort of interference can seriously damage well-meaning architectural practices.
'The chemotherapy was horrid'
As trim as ever, Foster, who has been married three times and has five children, seems fit and healthy, light on his feet and mentally sharp. So it comes as a surprise to learn of his battle with bowel cancer a decade ago, and of the fact that he can no longer fly solo, having suffered a heart attack. "For whatever reason," he says, "Deyan Sudjic played down these events in his biography. I did explain in some detail how I had worked my way through these life-threatening conditions. I certainly had no intention of letting up, neither then nor now. The day after I was told I had cancer, I had to present the Riba gold medal to Barcelona; and there was so much else to do, so many commitments.
"The chemotherapy was pretty horrid, I have to say, but I got through it by reading Lance Armstrong's book [It's Not About the Bike]. I bought a racing bike, and though I didn't quite manage to win the Tour de France [as Armstrong did in 1999, after fighting off testicular cancer], I've cycled marathons ever since." As a boy, he used to cycle to the Lakes and back to Levenshulme in a day; today, he tackles the Alps and the Pyrenees, his most memorable ride being a five-day jaunt along the precipitous Camino de Santiago, the 485-mile medieval pilgrimage route from France into Spain.
As another 75th birthday present to himself, Foster has commissioned a car from racing car restorers Crosthwaite & Gardiner. This is not any car, but a replica of Buckminster Fuller's legendary Dymaxion. US inventor Fuller, born in 1895, is best known for his geodesic domes, but he wanted to create a car that could fly, that could whisk drivers off roads and drop them at lightweight aluminium homes planted anywhere they fancied. The Dymaxion, a 20ft-long three-wheeler that looked part-airliner, part-yacht and part-whale, was the first step. "I've admired the look and the idea of these cars for many years," says Foster. "Yes, they were flawed, but they were a brave attempt to connect the car to architecture. They were just astonishing."
The zero-carbon mini-city
Foster met Fuller in the US in 1971, and the two worked on projects together until the inventor's death 12 years later. It was Fuller who asked Foster how much his hangar-like Sainsbury Centre for the Visual Arts, built in Norwich in the 1970s, weighed. Until then, this was not a question British architects, or indeed any architects, gave much thought to. What does it matter, as long as it stays up and shelters its occupants? Foster bothered to find out: the answer was 5,619 tons (the Empire State Building, by way of comparison, is said to weigh 370,000 tons).
Fuller's question has been used as the title of a forthcoming documentary, How Much Does Your Building Weigh, Mr Foster?, made with the help of his wife Elena. "One of the things it tries to say is that we should do more with less," the architect says of the film. "Today, I'm trying to get this message across not just through single buildings, but on a citywide level.
"Just now, for example, we're working on our Masdar City project in Abu Dhabi. This is an attempt to create a zero-carbon, zero-waste mini-city with a population of around 50,000 in a hostile desert climate – with, I hope, some lessons for cities worldwide. The idea is that conventional cars are housed in parking silos on the edges of what is, in effect, a contemporary walled city. Without cars, the streets inside the walls can be narrow, so they're both pedestrian-friendly and shady. But, so people can get around, there are proposals to create a level below pedestrian streets with guided electric cars. You'd call them by phone and they'd come to you; but once out of the city, they could also be driven like a conventional car. All this is based on ideas I discussed with Bucky years ago."
Masdar City, raised on a seven-metre podium so its electric cars can travel freely below the streets, recalls the fantasy future cities depicted in the pages of the Eagle, the weekly boys' comic first published in 1950, and one that Foster and other architects of his generation found compelling. Its strips were influenced by sci-fi fantasy as well as by the latest projects of Frank Lloyd Wright, whose buildings Foster visited while a student at Yale.
Where Masdar City differs is that its architecture is based on traditional Arabic precedent: it makes use of layers of sun-defeating decorative screens, cooling towers, narrow passageways, shade and oasis-like squares. If Middle Eastern cities of the future can develop along similar lines, they will be able to contain sprawl while being models of environmental good manners. It does seem a better idea to have a dozen new small walkable satellite cities close to Abu Dhabi rather than an Abu Dhabi too big for its urban robes. It's a project – the first part of which opens this year – that shows Foster and his practice still at the cutting edge of architecture and design.
For all his worldly success and professional esteem, and despite the fact that Foster and Partners is one enormous machine for making buildings (sometimes a little too slickly), Foster still exudes the curiosity of that enchanted boy looking out of his window at a world of wonderful machines. "I've never been busier," he says. "I'm amazed to be here still and doing all this. But then I look at Oscar Niemeyer in Rio, who was a hero of mine when I was a student at Manchester. Oscar's still busy at work at 102, so there's hope. In any case, I just wouldn't know how to stop."
Guggenheim plans extension in Spanish nature reserve
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
Local Basque officials rail against decision taken in New York to place new Guggenheim in nature reserve
The Guggenheim Museum has become the emblem of the northern Spanish city of Bilbao and its main tourist attraction, but now attempts to spread its magic by building an extension in a nearby nature reserve have run into fierce opposition.
Provincial authorities want to call an international competition for a museum extension in the bucolic surroundings of the coastal Urdaibai Biosphere Reserve, 25 miles from Bilbao, hoping it will help boost the local economy in the same way the Guggenheim helped Bilbao.
"People in Urdaibai are worried because unemployment is growing and traditional industries are in decline. The museum would be a great boost," said Andoni Ortuzar, local head of the Basque Nationalist party.
The move has provoked concern that authorities might choose to place a building as loud and intrusive as the main museum, designed by Frank Gehry, in the unspoilt surroundings of a nature park which boasts some of Spain's finest surfing beaches. It has also run into the opposition of the regional Basque government, which has threatened to veto a competition.
The project has the enthusiastic backing of the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, which also runs museums in New York, Berlin, Venice and Abu Dhabi. The foundation's director, Richard Armstrong, told a recent conference that he wanted the Urdaibai extension to become the "first important museum of the 21st century".
The foundation, however, sees the extension as very different from the dazzling building that towers over the River Nervion in Bilbao. "It would not be an architectural icon, but a landscape one," Armstrong said.
"The idea is to repeat the success, but not the model," added the Bilbao Guggenheim director, Juan Ignacio Vidarte.
The plan aims to raze a summer camp built in 1925 in the village of Sukarrieta and replace it with "an innovative ecological museum", with an emphasis on the "creative process rather than the finished product", according to the Guggenheim chief curator, Nancy Spector.
Critics have accused the Guggenheim of looking for a free new museum, given that the Urdaibai building would be paid for by local taxpayers.
Some local commentators already complain that the big decisions affecting the Bilbao Guggenheim are made in New York. "In the really important decisions the Basque and provincial governments have only been there to give their approval to what is decided in New York," said a former adviser to the museum, Javier González de Durana.
Provincial authorities said they still hoped to persuade the Basque regional government to go ahead with the architectural competition and that, if they did not get support, they would postpone it until a new government was elected.
Architect designs set for opera in former gulag
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010
Temporary bookshop is open and shut case
Posted by The Sheet in Architecture News on June 30, 2010